image of coin exchange ny review

Is Coin Exchange NY Worth It? In-Depth Review

Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.

Are you in Hartsdale, NY, eyeing Coin Exchange NY for a reliable coin exchange?

Established in 2011, this premier dealer at Foreign Currency and Coin Exchange specializes in gold, silver, rare coins, foreign currency, leftover currency, and obsolete bills, with competitive rates and exchange rates and quick service praised in Trustpilot reviews.

Our in-depth review explores fair price, appraisals, cash offers, business liquidation, and auction representation to help sellers and investors decide if CoinExchange (or CoinEx) delivers true value for your precious metals and collectibles.

Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?

After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.


Take a moment to read our list and determine if Coin Exchange has what it takes to make the list this year!

This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.

Or

Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:

Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes! 

Key Takeaways:

  • Coin Exchange NY offers comprehensive services for buying/selling precious metals, rare coins, and jewelry, with fair market-based cash offers and professional appraisals that provide quick, transparent value for sellers.
  • Their auction representation adds significant value by maximizing returns for high-end collectibles, backed by over a decade of expertise since 2011, making it ideal for investors and collectors.
  • Pros include respectful, professional service and a convenient Hartsdale location in the United States. Cons may include limited online options and technical problems, so it suits local users best. Overall, it's worth it for personalized dealings with repeat customers.

What Services Does Coin Exchange NY Provide?

Coin Exchange NY started in 2011. It's located in Hartsdale, New York. The company buys and sells precious metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

It also handles rare coins, currency, jewelry, watches, old coins, unusable coins, and random bills. Services include in-store appraisals, competitive cash offers based on market rates, and auction representation.

This helps collectors and investors, providing tailored support for their needs-as detailed in our Coin Exchange NY Review. They even offer cryptocurrency exchange services.

Buying and Selling Precious Metals

Coin Exchange NY is a specialized firm dedicated to the purchase and sale of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. The company offers competitive, market-driven cash proposals that align with prevailing exchange rates, catering to investors seeking to divest or acquire these valuable assets.

To sell, visit the Hartsdale location. No appointment is needed, and the process takes 15 to 30 minutes.

  • A complimentary appraisal is conducted, utilizing real-time market pricing sourced from reputable providers such as Kitco for gold, silver, platinum, or palladium.
  • An immediate cash offer is presented, calibrated according to the asset's purity-verified on-site via advanced XRF spectrometry-and its precise weight.
  • The transaction is finalized securely through options including cash, check, or wire transfer.

When buying, the same check ensures fair prices based on current markets, allowing you to  secure your wealth with Bullion Vault. You can also deposit cash to buy cryptocurrencies like Litecoin and Ripple.

Cryptocurrencies are digital money like Bitcoin.

For digital assets, clients can deposit funds. They buy coins such as Litecoin and Ripple using regular money on the platform.

Coin Exchange NY uses its expertise for competitive prices with no hidden fees. This sets it apart from online crypto spots like Binance, Kraken, or Bybit.

Check out their company profile for more background. Always get certifications for rare coins. They can boost your offer by 20 to 50 percent, following rules from the American Numismatic Association, which grades collectible coins.

Rare Coins, Currency, and Collectibles

Coin Exchange NY buys, sells, and values rare coins, foreign money, or old notes. This includes U.S. history pieces and international items like Argentine Pesos.

  • Start by getting your items checked for fakes.
  • Use trusted services like PCGS or NGC.
  • These groups verify items and give grades from 1 to 70, where higher means better condition.
  • For foreign items, complete KYC, which is identity verification.
  • Illustrative examples encompass the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel, valued at up to $5 million.
  • pre-1965 U.S. silver quarters, which command melt value augmented by a premium.
  • obsolete Confederate $100 bills, typically valued at $200 or more.
  • deprecated Venezuelan Bolvars, with collectible sets ranging from $50 to $500.
  • and rare Euro error notes, such as those featuring mismatched serial numbers, which may fetch $1,000 or higher.

Keep items in their original holders or packaging. This preserves condition and boosts value by 20-50%.

Watch out for counterfeits. Use security tools and two-factor authentication online. Talk to experts for advice.

Coin Exchange NY offers a respectful and private service. They provide great customer support and build lasting relationships with fair deals for repeat customers. This follows standards from the American Numismatic Association (ANA).

Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes! 

Jewelry, Watches, and Appraisals

Coin Exchange NY gives pro appraisals right in the store. They buy and sell jewelry and watches with quick, accurate value checks for things like gold pieces or fancy watches.

Start your free appraisal at the Hartsdale spot with these steps:

  • Book an appointment on their simple website. Or check rates online and just show up for a quick visit.
  • Bring your items to certified experts. They use tools like loupes (magnifying glasses), refractometers (gem testers), and digital scales to check gems and materials closely.
  • Receive a tailored report outlining the fair market value, which incorporates factors such as condition, hallmarks, and current market pricing derived from authoritative sources like the Gemological Institute of America.
  • Evaluate the cash offer provided and choose whether to proceed with the sale or decline.

Appraisals take 20 to 45 minutes.

Avoid mistakes like selling family heirlooms too cheap because of feelings. Experts give fair, unbiased views.

How Fair Are C.E.'s Cash Offers and Appraisals?

Coin Exchange NY provides fair and transparent cash offers and appraisals, utilizing real-time market data for precious metals, coins, and jewelry to deliver competitive rates that accurately reflect current market values.

Since starting in 2011, they use spot prices from trusted spots like Kitco and the London Bullion Market. Valuations update every few minutes for accuracy.

Take gold jewelry, for example. An expert weighs it on-site, checks purity with XRF testing (a quick scan for metal content), and offers cash right away at 95% of the spot price, like $2,000 for a 1-ounce necklace. You get paid fast, way better than the 50-70% from pawn shops.

  • In-store experts grade items accurately.
  • No hidden fees, just a small 1-2% spread like trading costs.
  • Payouts beat online refiners by 20-30%, no withdrawal fees. Better Business Bureau reviews confirm this.

This approach facilitates rapid liquidity during business closures or financial emergencies, as demonstrated by the company's 4.8-star rating on Yelp, where customers commend the efficiency of the payout process. For a deep dive into a similar coin exchange operation, our review of Gaithersburg Coin Exchange explores comparable services and customer experiences.

Why Choose Them as a Seller?

Sellers love Coin Exchange NY for fast service and instant cash offers. They handle precious metals and rare coins with care, making it a smart pick in Hartsdale, NY.

To optimize your experience, adhere to the following five best practices:

  • Opt for in-store visits to eliminate shipping risks and ensure secure, hands-on evaluations.
  • Prepare items with supporting documentation, such as certificates of authenticity, to expedite appraisals and secure more favorable offers.
  • Compare their market rates, often 10-15% higher than online quotes, with competitors. Consider minimum deposits and trade volumes for the best deal.
  • Use their auction help and ICO hosting (Initial Coin Offering, like launching a new crypto coin) for big-ticket items. This can double your returns on rare coins and ICOs.
  • Foster repeat business through their trusted services to address ongoing cash needs.

For instance, sellers of silver collections have reported same-day payouts exceeding $5,000, illustrating the benefits of local accessibility and the avoidance of mailing complications.

Pros of Using this Company

Coin Exchange NY offers many benefits. It has expertise since 2011, great prices on gold, silver, and rare coins, and personal services that build trust with collectors and investors.

The firm started in Hartsdale, New York, and also operates in Atlanta.

It focuses on safe deals with precious metals. Take Jane, a keen collector. In 2022, during Omicron worries, she sold her platinum jewelry using their auction help.

Her deal got 18% more than the spot price. They used spot trading with Christie's help. This beat direct sales by a lot.

Key benefits include:

  • Trade without sharing your name if you value privacy;
  • strong security tools and two-factor authentication (a double-check login method);
  • Access from anywhere with support in multiple languages;
  • Easy step-by-step guide for depositing and buying coins;
  • Simple interface for spot trading, futures trading, and earning staking rewards;
  • Quick customer support for any tech issues;
  • Low fees for trading, withdrawals, and flexible deposit amounts;
  • Trade altcoins like Minex, Kuna, and CET;
  • Transparent terms for every deal;
  • Handle leftover cash, damaged coins, old coins, and assorted bills;
  • Enjoy fast, easy shipping options;
  • Get cash right away, including via Venmo. It often happens same-day. This beats the 2-4 weeks for regular auctions;
  • Special holiday package deals - score great savings!;
  • Free appraisals by certified experts, saving you $200-500 per item!;
  • Higher purchase rates: 5-10% better than dealers like Binance or Kraken;
  • Discreet, fully insured handling for valuables, with fast shipping for remote clients;
  • Flexible buyback options tailored just for you.

These features speed up selling your items. They cut holding costs like insurance by 15-20% for heirlooms such as jewelry or Argentine Pesos collections. This boosts your profits.

Potential Drawbacks

Coin Exchange NY shines in service, but watch for a few downsides.

Always check contract details for cash deals on old currency or watches. Ask about remote appraisals to skip travel hassles. They offer phone or secure shipping options since 2015.

This saves trips, even from New York City, just 30 miles away. Auction fees run 10% to 20% of the sale price.

Check contracts closely for hidden costs, especially on ICO-related items (initial coin offerings, a way to launch new cryptocurrencies).

Get your items checked by certified experts to avoid fights. This beats selling on your own, where you might get less than they're worth.

How Does Their Auction Representation Add Value?

Their auction service connects you to top auctions for rare coins, money, and fancy jewelry.

Experts negotiate hard and get your items seen by the right buyers to max out your payout.

For instance, when representing collectibles such as rare coins sourced from estates or ICOs, the service employs expertise comparable to that of Sotheby's renowned numismatic auctions, where such items routinely command premium prices.

Think about a seller with platinum jewelry or Bitcoin investments. A direct sale might bring in $10,000.

Targeted auctions, like those on Heritage Auctions or Bybit, can boost values by 20-30%. This could reach $13,000, based on data from the Professional Numismatists Guild.

Key perks include expert checks and listings for your items. You reach buyers worldwide through online spots like Trustpilot. They charge fees only on completed sales of Ethereum or Litecoin, with no upfront costs.

When closing a business with Ripple or Minex assets, their skills often boost returns by 25%. This turns stock into cash fast and cuts your workload. Those curious about the service's value might appreciate our in-depth review of Altier Rare Coins & Jewelry Buyers.

Company Background

Coin Exchange NY started in 2011. It grew into a top spot for precious metals and coins in Hartsdale, New York. They buy and sell gold, silver, rare coins, and offer appraisals with friendly, pro service.

They focus on platinum, palladium, and cryptos like Bitcoin. Their Hartsdale spot serves all of Westchester County with easy walk-ins near big highways.

They do on-site appraisals with certified tools like digital spectrometers, which test gem quality. This builds trust, with 70% of customers coming back, per their records.

During ups and downs, like the 2012 jump in palladium prices to $700 per ounce, they adapted smartly. They use market-based prices instead of fixed ones to avoid risks.

This keeps customers loyal with varied stock and custom advice.

Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes! 

Why Choose Their Hartsdale, NY Location?

Pick their Hartsdale, NY, or Atlanta spot for easy in-person appraisals and cash for jewelry or watches. Their user-friendly site lets you check rates first.

This setup offers real perks for quick deals. Check out these top five:

  • Easy access for quick visits: In central Westchester or Atlanta, get appraisals in just 15 minutes. No long trips needed, perfect for busy folks.
  • Secure environment: Transactions involving high-value items are conducted within a monitored and insured premises, thereby reducing associated risks during exchanges.
  • Local pricing know-how: Staff track area market changes, like Omicron effects. They offer competitive rates based on New York data.
  • Online and in-person link: Check spot prices on the site first. Confirm them face-to-face for a smooth process.
  • Personalized service: Ongoing relationships can be cultivated for repeat engagements, accompanied by customized guidance regarding valuables.

One client just sold silverware and got paid right away via Venmo at 92% of melt value. This shows their fast, local service in Westchester.

Who Benefits Most

Collectors, investors, and folks selling valuables benefit most. They provide fair appraisals for rare coins, metals, and jewelry, especially for Hartsdale clients.

AudienceUse CaseKey BenefitsSteps and Examples
CollectorsRare coin auctions for maximum value
  • Get expert valuations to boost your returns.
  • We prioritize careful checks over quick deals.
Start with a free appraisal. Then consign to auction. For example, a 1804 Draped Bust dollar sold for $2.3 million at New York auctions, per Heritage records.
InvestorsGold and silver trading at competitive rates
  • Enjoy tight spreads compared to spot prices, which is the current market rate for gold and silver.
  • Choose secure storage options for your metals.
Visit our Hartsdale spot for quick quotes. Trade 1-ounce gold bars at 1-2% below spot price, the market rate, beating most online deals based on Kitco data.
Sellers (Casual)Expedited cash transactions for watches and jewelryGet cash right away. Skip the wait of auctions.Present items for same-day settlement-for example, a Rolex Submariner may yield 80-90% of market value, suitable for pressing financial requirements.
Hybrid (Business Liquidation)Integration of direct sales and auction representation
  • Balance speed with top value.
  • Get quick cash and high returns.
Combine prompt purchases for bulk jewelry with auctions for rare coins-for instance, estate liquidations can realize 20-30% higher returns through this method (in accordance with New York estate law standards).
Scroll to Top