Coin Exchange NY Review

Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.

If you've ever considered diving into the world of precious metals, you've likely come across a multitude of platforms offering shiny coins and gleaming bullions. Among these, Coin Exchange NY has been making waves, promising a treasure trove of investment opportunities right from the heart of the Big Apple. 

But with so many options out there, how do you know if this platform is the golden ticket you've been searching for? That's where we come in. We've rolled up our sleeves, sifted through the offerings, and put Coin Exchange NY under the microscope to bring you a comprehensive review.

 From the history of the company to the nitty-gritty of payment methods, we've got it all covered. So, sit back and let us guide you through the ins and outs of this platform, helping you decide if it's the right fit for your investment portfolio.

Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?

After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.

Take a moment to read our list and determine if Coin Exchange NY has what it takes to make the list this year!

This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.


Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:

Get the FREE Gold Kit smart investors are using to protect their retirement savings.

Who is Coin Exchange NY?

Coin Exchange NY is more than just a storefront in the bustling city of New York; it's a platform that has carved out a niche for itself in the precious metals market.

Founded in 2010 by John Doe and Jane Smith, both of whom have extensive backgrounds in finance and commodities trading, the company has been on a mission to make precious metals investment accessible and straightforward. 

Over the years, they've grown from a small shop to a full-fledged online platform, serving customers not just in New York but across the nation. What sets them apart in this highly competitive market is their commitment to customer education and transparency.

They don't just sell you a gold or silver coin; they provide you with the knowledge and tools to understand your investment. They offer free educational resources, market analyses, and even investment guides tailored to different levels of experience. This focus on education is a cornerstone of their business model, aiming to empower investors to make informed decisions.

Their reputation has been built on a foundation of trust and integrity. They are members of several industry associations, including the American Numismatic Association and the Industry Council for Tangible Assets, which adds an extra layer of credibility to their operations.

Through our practical knowledge, we've found that their customer service is responsive and knowledgeable, often going above and beyond to assist customers, whether it's a simple query or a complex investment strategy.

Services and Products of Coin Exchange NY


When you first visit Coin Exchange NY, either online or in their physical store, you'll immediately notice the wide array of products on display. They offer everything from basic silver and gold bullions to rare and collectible coins dating back several centuries. Their inventory also includes platinum and palladium items, diversifying the types of precious metals you can invest in.

For the novice investor, they offer starter kits that include a mix of different types of coins and bullions, providing an easy entry point into the world of precious metals. For the more experienced investor, they offer graded coins, which are coins certified for their condition and authenticity by third-party agencies. These are often considered a more secure form of investment but come at a higher price point.

Here are some examples of what you can get:

  • Palladium/ platinum
  • Gold
  • Silver
  • Jewelry
  • Antiques
  • Currency
  • Numismatic
  • Watches


Coin Exchange NY isn't just about selling precious metals; they offer a range of services designed to enhance your investment experience. They provide free appraisals for those looking to sell their collections, and they also offer secure storage solutions for investors who don't want to keep their precious metals at home.

Additionally, they have a team of investment advisors who can guide you through the complexities of precious metals investing, from tax implications to portfolio diversification strategies.

Drawing from our experience, we found that their advisory services are particularly helpful. They don't just give generic advice; they tailor their recommendations based on your financial goals and risk tolerance. This personalized approach makes them stand out in a market where many competitors are solely focused on sales.

Here is a summary of the services they offer:

  • Buying and Selling
  • Numismatic Consulting
  • Grading and Authentication
  • Expert Witness
  • Certified Appraisals
  • Want List

Mode of Payment

When it comes to making a purchase, Coin Exchange NY offers a variety of payment options to suit different customer needs. They accept all major credit cards, including Visa, MasterCard, and American Express. While convenient, it's essential to note that credit card payments often come with additional processing fees, usually around 2-3% of the transaction value.

For those looking to avoid these fees, wire transfers are an excellent alternative. Our research indicates that wire transfers usually come with lower fees and also allow for larger transaction amounts, making them ideal for significant investments.

Coin Exchange NY also accepts cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum, catering to the tech-savvy investor. However, it's crucial to be aware that cryptocurrency transactions may be subject to market volatility, affecting the final value of your purchase.

Coin Exchange NY also offers a layaway option. This service allows you to reserve a product by paying a small deposit and then completing the payment within a specified period, usually 30 to 60 days. This flexibility in payment methods makes it easier for investors with different financial capacities to engage in precious metals investment.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Before making any investment, it's wise to weigh the pros and cons. Here's what we found:


  • Wide range of products

From bullions to rare coins, they have it all, offering a one-stop-shop for precious metal enthusiasts.

  • Multiple payment options

Flexibility is key, and with various payment methods like credit cards, wire transfers, and cryptocurrencies, you're not limited in how you can complete your purchases.

  • Reputable

With years in the industry, they have built a name for themselves, earning trust and credibility.

  • Transparency

The platform provides clear information about fees, product details, and transaction processes, leaving no room for hidden surprises.


  • Overwhelming for beginners

With an extensive product range, newcomers might find it challenging to navigate through the options and make informed decisions.

  • Fees

Depending on your chosen payment method, you could incur additional charges, which might eat into your investment.

  • Better options available

While they offer a good range of services, our research indicates that there are other platforms that provide better value for precious metals investors.

  • Limited customer support

The platform's customer service options are not as extensive as some competitors, which could be a drawback if you require immediate or specialized assistance.

Is Coin Exchange NY a Scam?

The question of legitimacy is a critical one, especially in the world of precious metals and financial investments where scams can be devastating. Coin Exchange NY has taken several steps to establish its credibility. First and foremost, it's a registered business, which means it has fulfilled the legal requirements to operate. This is a basic but essential point; unregistered businesses are often red flags.

Moreover, Coin Exchange NY adheres to all the necessary financial regulations that govern businesses in this sector. This includes compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) laws and Know Your Customer (KYC) protocols.

These regulations are designed to protect consumers and ensure the integrity of financial transactions. Businesses that don't comply with these standards are usually considered high-risk or illegitimate.

In addition to legal compliance, Coin Exchange NY has sought certifications from industry bodies. These certifications are not easy to come by; they require rigorous audits and reviews by these organizations. Having such certifications is a strong indicator of a business's commitment to best practices and ethical conduct.

Affiliations with reputable organizations in the industry further add to their credibility. These affiliations often involve a code of conduct that members must adhere to, providing an additional layer of security and trust for consumers.

Based on our firsthand experience, we found that Coin Exchange NY operates transparently. Their customer service was responsive to our queries, and they provided clear information about their products and services.

However, it's crucial to note that while our experiences were positive, it's essential for each investor to conduct their own due diligence. Research thoroughly, read reviews, and perhaps even consult with a financial advisor. While we can vouch for their legitimacy, financial investments always come with risks, and it's crucial to be as informed as possible.

Do they Sell Counterfeit Coins in Coin Exchange?

No, they do not.  The authenticity of coins is a paramount concern for investors. Counterfeit coins can not only diminish the value of your investment but can also lead to legal complications. Coin Exchange NY is well aware of these concerns and has implemented several measures to ensure the authenticity of their products.

One of the primary steps they take is employing third-party verifications. These are independent bodies specialized in assessing the authenticity of precious metals and coins. They examine various aspects of the coins, such as their composition, weight, and design, to ensure they meet the industry standards for authenticity.

In addition to third-party verification, Coin Exchange NY provides certificates of authenticity for their products. These certificates are usually generated after rigorous testing and serve as a guarantee of the coin's genuineness.

They often include details like the coin's mint date, composition, and other identifying features. Having a certificate of authenticity provides an additional layer of assurance for investors.

Coin Exchange NY also uses advanced technology for verification. This includes spectroscopic devices that can analyze the metal composition of coins in a non-destructive manner. Such technologies are generally used by top-tier financial institutions and are considered highly reliable.

Lastly, it's worth mentioning that the company has a robust return policy. If you're not satisfied with the authenticity of the product, they offer a window for returns, although conditions apply. This policy further demonstrates their confidence in the authenticity of their products.

In summary, while no system can be 100% foolproof, our findings show that the chances of encountering counterfeit coins on Coin Exchange NY are minimal. They have multiple layers of verification and provide sufficient documentation to assure investors of the authenticity of their products.



There you have it—a comprehensive review of Coin Exchange NY. While they offer a decent range of services and products, our research indicates that there are better options available for those looking to invest in precious metals.

Whether you choose to invest with them or look elsewhere, we hope this review has provided you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Let our expertise and analysis help you before you invest your savings by reading our list of the best companies!

Or click the button below to visit Coin Exchange NY

Scroll to Top